Completed Report against Silent Rebel

Discussion in 'TTT Staff/Player Reports' started by ridge, Oct 30, 2014.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. ridge

    ridge VIP

    Name of Staff/Player:
    Silent Rebel
    Steam ID of Staff/Player:
    STEAM_0:1:72670717
    Which Server:
    Vanilla
    Which Map:
    Minecraft B5
    Which Round:
    8 until map changes
    Time of Occurence:
    Around 11:28 PM PST
    Reason For Report:
    I pushed someone in the nether... he was no where near the lava, therefore he was not close to falling into the lava. He shot me and RDMed me.​
    Evidence And/Or Witnesses:
    Just the video
     
  2. Silent Rebel

    Silent Rebel Lead Shitposter VIP

    In the video, you can see the Lambert pushed the innocent towards the lava with his crowbar. If he was at a slightly better angle, the innocent would have fallen in and burned. This is how I perceived the situation. I will tag my admin, @Muffin, to give his thoughts on the situation.
     
  3. Muffin

    Muffin Fresh Baked VIP

    As Silent mentioned, it is not unreasonable to think you attempted to hit the guy into that little patch of lava. I will wait for others to present their opinions on this situation.
     
    Last edited: Oct 31, 2014
  4. Darktooth

    Darktooth I was #1 VIP

    While the video doesn't make it seem like this would be the case, from Silent Rebel's POV, you had looked like you were about to push someone into the small lava pit to the side of you. It is not unreasonable to think that you were about to try and kill someone with the lava by pushing him into it, especially when it looks just like that in his POV.

    EDIT: After rewatching the video, you do send the player at an angle that moves directly towards the lava pit, so I'd say it was a valid kill based on these circumstances.
     
  5. Enigmatica

    Enigmatica The Song Lives On Banned

    As others have stated, it does look like you attempted to push him into lava, and from Silent Rebel's POV, it may have looked even worse

    This report has been resolved, if you have any further questions, you can message a staff member to have this unlocked.
     
  6. Turquoise

    Turquoise Princess of Vanilla VIP

    Going to agree with the dandy dodger blue people above, but it's a good idea to not shove someone towards lava generally. Can help prevent this issue from occurring in the future.

    EDIT: Ninja'd by a Lead Admin again ;-;
     
  7. Enigmatica

    Enigmatica The Song Lives On Banned

    Report reopened. It is obvious that the player is pushed further inland and not towards the lava. For some reason, I overlooked this beforehand. @Silent Rebel
     
  8. Sinz

    Sinz crumble VIP Silver

    @Muffin,

    I also believe that the player was pushed more inland than towards the lava.

    Even in @Silent Rebel's perspective he would have seen that the player came closer to his player model and further away from the lava pool.

    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
     
  9. ThatBox

    ThatBox Not this box, that one. VIP

    @Silent Rebel also had a few seconds after the crowbar push had elapsed to see the distance between the lava and the player had become greater. The player was pushed away from the lava and yet it seems Silent Rebel still killed Lambert, therefore RDMing him off the suspicion that he was pushed towards the lava..
     
  10. Darktooth

    Darktooth I was #1 VIP

    I've relooked at the evidence provided and deeply apologize for my decision making. This situation does seem more suspicion than hard evidence.
     
  11. Silent Rebel

    Silent Rebel Lead Shitposter VIP

    All I saw a player attempting to push another player towards the lava, even if he may have messed up a little and it wasn't a very good push. I viewed this as a reasonable kill, but if the admins think I am wrong, I will take a slay and be more careful in the future.
     
  12. I concur with the allegations of this being RDM; Lambert can clearly be seen pushing that player away from danger, despite the fact that it probably wasn't his initial intention, thus not being a legitimate kill.
     
  13. Muffin

    Muffin Fresh Baked VIP

    Alright then, Silent Rebel will serve a slay. Thank you for reporting.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.